Marshall DG et al., 1920-06-19: A British Army malaria consultant's 1920 letter reporting methylene blue use in more than 3,000 malaria cases at the Edinburgh War Hospital, Bangour, during and after the First World War, with no toxicity beyond mild bladder irritation , the wartime military record the claim needs.
The total quantity of methylene-blue used in one hospital alone (the Edinburgh War Hospital, Bangour) amounted to over two pounds in weight, representing about 5000 doses of 3 gr. each. The number of malaria cases treated numbered over 3000.
1334
Marshall DG et al., 1920-06-19: A British Army malaria consultant's 1920 letter reporting methylene blue use in more than 3,000 malaria cases at the Edinburgh War Hospital, Bangour, during and after the First World War, with no toxicity beyond mild bladder irritation , the wartime military record the claim needs. C5 , Marshall DG. The 'toxicity' of methylene-blue. Lancet 1920;195(5051):1334 (dated Edinburgh, 10 June 1920). English, United Kingdom. The Lancet 1920 issue scan on Internet Archive, _djvu.txt route; OCR errors in the source (e.g. 'SirR,, ', 'wa,') are left uncorrected in the file and the excerpt was cut from the machine text. Lu et al. 2018 cite it as 195(5051):1334, which is correct: issue 5051 of 19 June 1920 falls in vol. 195 (Jan-Jun 1920). The Internet Archive identifier carries 198. Rule-5 detail: hospital case series / service audit, N = 'over 3000' malaria cases, 5000 doses of 3 gr. each (about 0.194 g), oral, one hospital (Edinburgh War Hospital, Bangour) plus Scottish Command practice, country United Kingdom, no control group, no funder or conflict statement. Marshall also records, verbatim: 'in many cases favourable results were obtained, the efficacy of methylene-blue in cutting short attacks was distinctly inferior to quinine' but that it 'frequently proved a valuable remedy in preventing relapses', and that some patients 'received over 400 gr. in a course of treatment extending over several weeks' with only slight bladder irritation. Study type: uncontrolled series.
