United States et al. v. Rutherford et al., 442 U.S. 544 (1979)

Government Record · Supreme Court of the United States (Marshall, J., unanimous) · June 18, 1979

Supreme Court of the United States (Marshall, 1979-06-18: The Supreme Court held unanimously that the Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act admits no exception for terminally ill patients and reversed the Tenth Circuit's laetrile exemption. The opinion records the FDA's administrative hearings, the Commissioner's 29 July 1977 decision at 42 Fed. Reg. 39768, and full judicial review.

we have no license to depart from the plain language of the Act, for Congress could reasonably have intended to shield terminal patients from ineffectual or unsafe drugs

p. 555

Supreme Court of the United States (Marshall, 1979-06-18: The Supreme Court held unanimously that the Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act admits no exception for terminally ill patients and reversed the Tenth Circuit's laetrile exemption. The opinion records the FDA's administrative hearings, the Commissioner's 29 July 1977 decision at 42 Fed. Reg. 39768, and full judicial review. Court record; no funder or conflicts. Key procedural facts for the 'no fair hearing' claim: the Commissioner opened proceedings by Federal Register announcement (42 Fed. Reg. 10066), gave notice to known laetrile proponents, held hearings, and issued a written decision; the District Court and Tenth Circuit reviewed it; the Supreme Court heard argument 25 April 1979. Filed as No. 78-605. Alternate host: tile.loc.gov copy of the same U.S. Reports volume.