Sackett v. EPA (2012)

Court Filing · Supreme Court of the United States (Scalia, J., for a unanimous Court; Alito, J., concurring) · March 21, 2012

U.S. Supreme Court, March 2012, unanimous: the Sacketts could go to court to challenge EPA's 2007 compliance order on their small lot near Priest Lake, Idaho. EPA had refused them a hearing, and under its theory the penalties could reach $75,000 a day. The Court said efficiency of regulation does not beat the right to judicial review.

$75,000 per day—up to $37,500 for the statutory violation and up to an additional $37,500 for violating the compliance order

123

U.S. Supreme Court, March 2012, unanimous: the Sacketts could go to court to challenge EPA's 2007 compliance order on their small lot near Priest Lake, Idaho. EPA had refused them a hearing, and under its theory the penalties could reach $75,000 a day. The Court said efficiency of regulation does not beat the right to judicial review.